Pacific Northwest Baseline Specification Review

  • 12 Urban-Large City
  • 9 Non-profit
  • 3 Not provided
  • 10 New Construction
  • 2 Rehab

Cabinetry & Millwork

Cabinetry & Millwork
Data Summary

  • All the projects had requirements for cabinets limiting formaldehyde based binders or formaldehyde emissions.
  • About 20% of the projects specified CA 93120/CARB Phase II compliant.
  • About 65% of projects specified composite wood products that contain no urea formaldehyde.
  • A majority of projects specified cabinet manufacturers, but did not include specific product lines.
  • Nearly all projects specified cabinets with a factory finish.
  • About 20% of projects specified a laminate (HPL or melamine) or thermofoil finish for exterior faces, with an additional 35% specifying laminate only for interior surfaces.
  • All projects specified wood trim/base in at least some part of the units.
  • Most projects specified rubber wall base somewhere. None specified vinyl wall base.
  • About 45% of projects specified MDF for some trim or as an alternative to wood in at least some places.
  • 60% of projects that allowed or specified MDF required that it be free of urea-formaldehyde or formaldehyde-free.

Doors

Doors
Data Summary

  • About 90% of projects specified doors with a composite core, and about 25% specified hollow core doors with a composite face.
  • About 60% of projects that included wood doors with composite core or facing specified no urea formaldehyde - one project further specified that all components be formaldehyde-free.
  • Only 2 projects specified a particular product or series; the others provided general information about which materials should be used and often included approved manufacturers.
  • Over 80% of projects specified factory finished wood doors with an additional 10% specifying a combination of factory finished and site finished.

Countertops

Countertops
Data Summary

  • Plastic laminate dominates in the Pacific Northwest affordable housing projects reviewed - it was specified in about 90% of kitchens and about 70% of bathrooms.
  • One project avoided plastic laminate all together, specifying solid surface countertops in both kitchen and bath.
  • 25% specified quartz or solid surface as an alternate countertop to laminate.
  • Almost 65% of projects specified substrates with no urea formaldehyde, and about 10% specified formaldehyde-free materials.

Drywall

Drywall
Data Summary

  • One project had a specific recycled content requirement that called for either 10% post-consumer or 95% pre-consumer content - the latter of which would mean synthetic gypsum was definitely used. The Pacific Northwest is currently unique in their local access to gypsum boards with post-consumer content in the core.
  • No projects specified natural gypsum as a requirement.
  • Almost three quarters of projects specified wall and/or ceiling texture.

Flooring

Flooring
Data Summary

  • All projects specified vinyl flooring somewhere in the building, with the majority specifying it somewhere in the unit.
  • Over 90% of projects specified carpeting. About 80% of these required Green Label or Green Label Plus certification. (This industry-backed certification only covers some VOC emissions; some hazardous VOC and all non-VOC chemicals are excluded.) One project specified Cradle to Cradle Bronze.
  • Other flooring products specified include ceramic tile, laminate, and linoleum. Polyolefin sheet flooring was listed as an alternate to vinyl sheet in one project.
  • Over 80% of projects set VOC content limits on flooring adhesives consistent with SCAQMD 1168 requirements.
  • A wide variety of carpet pad was specified: 40% of projects specified fiber carpet pad. Other types specified include rubber, prime polyurethane, and rebond.

Insulation

Insulation
Data Summary

  • All projects specified use of fiber glass batt insulation.
  • About 35% of projects specified that fiber glass batts be formaldehyde-free and about 20% specified they have no urea-formaldehyde. As of October 2015, all residential fiber glass batt insulation made in the U.S. is formaldehyde-free.
  • Over 60% of projects specified blown fiber glass insulation for exterior walls.
  • Over 60% of projects list polyurethane spray foam (either 1- or 2-part) for sealing gaps or miscellaneous voids. One project specified a 2-part latex-based spray foam product for air sealing.

Paint

Paint
Data Summary

  • All projects reviewed specified a VOC content requirement.
  • All projects that specified flat paint, specified that it have <50 g/L VOCs. Most of these also specified a VOC limit of 100 g/L, including colorant added at the point of sale.
  • Over 60% of projects specified non-flat paint limited to <50 g/L VOCs. Most of these also  specified a VOC limit of 100 g/L, including colorant added at the point of sale.
  • No specific VOC requirements for tints were indicated except as noted above regarding VOC limits including colorant at point of sale.
  • About 20% of the projects specified paint that meets an older, less strict version of the Green Seal-11 standard.